Let’s Choose a Better MVP this Season
Thursday, December 25th, 2008Any given preseason, if I ask you, who you think will win MVP this season, you’ll probably throw out some names like Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Adrian Peterson, or LaDainian Tomlinson. Maybe not those exact players, but you get the idea: the names you pick will always, always, be on offense and they’ll probably line up in the backfield. Before the season starts no one is gutsy enough to say, “Actually, I think Brian Urlacher has a real shot this season.”
I could argue this is because of fantasy football and fans today care more about numbers than in the past, and to some extent perhaps this is true. It’s why most fans look at Trent Edwards and see a player who has thrown for at least 2 touchdowns in just one game this season, rather than a quarterback who has been pretty solid in his second season as a pro. He hit some rough spots but his wins/losses column (7-6) is pretty good, considering the team around him.
But fantasy football isn’t why fans don’t look to defense when picking an MVP. No, this habit goes back to the idea the quarterback is the most important player on the field, and the only time another position should win the award is when his value compensates for the lack of value at quarterback and keeps his team competitive. The only position where you can be certain a player is making this level of impact is running back.
Look at defense. Now, I know a disruptive defensive lineman is important, but is he the most valuable player in the NFL? Can he win football games? This argument is difficult because defenders rarely score touchdowns. They can be part of a unit that prevents opponents from scoring points, but is that the same thing?
Look at Dallas Cowboys defensive end DeMarcus Ware. If he tackles the quarterback behind the line of scrimmage three times this weekend in Philadelphia, he’ll break the single season sack record with 23. He’s been pretty doggone disruptive this season, no doubt about it. After all, one can only guess the number of times he’s pressured the quarterback and hurried him into a bad decision or the number of times he drew an extra blocker, freeing up someone else on the defense to sack the quarterback or create a disruption. He forces opposing offensive coordinators to game plan differently, to focus more attention on him. Dallas’s defense has been pretty good this season, ranking 4th against the pass and 8th in total yards allowed, but can one argue he is the league’s most valuable player?
How do we measure the value of an individual player in a game which stresses teamwork? Numbers, usually, but those numbers are dependent on the actions of the players surrounding the star, whether he is on offense or defense. Tom Brady passed for 50 touchdowns last season and certainly deserved the MVP award, but watching games in which he played at least one thing was certainly obvious: his offensive line gave him more than enough time in the pocket.
Players do not make things happen without the support of teammates, not in football. In baseball, sure, it’s possible. In basketball, yeah, there’s no doubt. But in football, players are in sync when things go right and out of sync when things go wrong. A quarterback may pass for 50 touchdowns in a season, but someone caught those passes and others threw blocks to give him an extra split-second to make a decision.
No, numbers alone do not justify an MVP. Intangible qualities, those things we have no certain way of measuring, such as leadership and tenacity and coolness under pressure, do. There are times a player may not put up the numbers of his peers, but he can rally his teammates around him and push them to give everything they have and just a little bit more. He is a valuable player.
Records are broken as a result of an alignment of the stars and a dash of luck for good measure. Teams winning games and performing beyond expectations or realistic boundaries; teams playing better than they look on paper; this is where we should look to find the MVP. Forget the stars that turn our fantasy teams into juggernauts; let’s instead look to the players who turn their teams into winners, even against the odds.


