Marshall’s Risk-Reward Will Make for an Interesting Offseason
Tuesday, January 26th, 2010Brandon Marshall is becoming a lightning rod for attention, and in all the wrong ways. He demanded a preseason trade and was met with a resounding “no” from new head coach Josh McDaniels, who, already under fire after trading former “franchise” quarterback Jay Cutler, was not about to lose another Pro Bowl. So, naturally, Marshall threw a tantrum that would make any two-year old proud: he batted down passes during practice and punted footballs away from ball boys standing mere feet from him.
Everyone knows what happened next: McDaniels benched him. Eighteen weeks later he benched him again, this time from participating in a meaningful game, one that could have launched the Broncos to the postseason (had they received some help, which they didn’t).
Ignoring Marshall’s antics for the time being, consider what happened after Marshall was benched. The Broncos lost to the Kansas City Chiefs, a team they had beaten to a pulp, 44-13, just a few weeks before. But they didn’t just “lose.” They lost their fourth straight and the eighth of their final ten. They were embarrassed at home, 44-24, by a division rival. They had missed the postseason for the second consecutive season.
Imagine if Marshall had played. Kyle Orton threw three interceptions without his favorite target on the field. Seeing the Broncos without Marshall was like watching the 49ers without Terrell Owens or the Vikings without Randy Moss. It was pitiful, really. The offense was outscored 34-14 in the second half just four weeks after outscoring the same Chiefs 30-7 in the final two quarters. Jabar Gaffney put up some impressive numbers — 14 receptions for 213 yards — but Orton never found him in the endzone. Maybe because he’s two inches shorter and 30 pounds lighter than Marshall.
That’s what Marshall brings to the table: size, physicality, and a presence. He has 307 receptions the past three seasons — only Wes Welker has more. His 3,710 receiving yards is matched only by the elites at his position, players like Andre Johnson, Larry Fitzgerald, Reggie Wayne, Randy Moss, and Roddy White (in that order). He’s been selected to the past two Pro Bowls and proven he can adapt to any kind of quarterback; Jay Cutler was the gunslinger and Kyle Orton was the game manager, but both threw Marshall the rock over 100 times each season they took snaps from the center.
At the end of the day, Marshall is the most intriguing prospect this offseason. As a restricted free agent there are plenty of rumors suggesting the team will trade him for value in this year’s draft. (Perhaps with hopes of drafting the next star wide receiver.) Some of the teams are more likely than others to end up with Marshall when 2010 kicks off, but these are my favorites with my thoughts on each.
Most Likely: Washington Redskins
Daniel Snyder rivals Jerry Jones in his desire to win and his willingness to spend money to do it. He’s not as wise as Jones, but he loves throwing money at players. Besides, someone like Marshall would be perfect for Washington’s (*yawn*) offense. But remember: the guy who has the final say in getting Marshall is none other than ex-Broncos coach Mike Shanahan. He drafted Marshall and might not mind getting him again to kick off his renovation of the ‘Skins.
Certainly a Possibility: Seattle Seahawks
Pete Carroll is the new sheriff in Seattle, and he’s brought some big guns with him, all of whom were at one point or another in Denver: Alex Gibbs, who turned Terrell Davis into a 2,000 yard rusher, Jeremy Bates, and Jedd Fisch, who Marshall said, “had us prepared week in and week out. He’s a guy who got the best out of me, no matter what.”
Well, Maybe: Baltimore Ravens
Joe Flacco needs a young wide receiver with loads of talent and Marshall might be the player to deliver. Problems stem from this situation, best described by Carroll County Times writer Aaron Wilson (also of Pro Football Talk):
“As one of the final eight playoff teams, the Ravens would be unable to sign an unrestricted free agent until they lose one of their own unrestricted free agents. Plus, the team can’t sign that player for more money than the free agent it loses.
“The Ravens would be allowed to sign just one player with a salary of $4.925 million or higher. They would be allowed to sign players with a first-year compensation level of $3.2 million that can’t climb any more than 30 percent in the subsequent years.”
In other words, Marshall might be above their price ceiling.
At the End of the Day: Denver Broncos
Whether Broncos fans or Josh McDaniels want Marshall in the locker room days one through six is debatable, but one thing is certain: he is a force to be reckoned on with on Sundays. He’s a 100-reception, 1,000 yard guarantee, and someone the Broncos will find difficult to replace with one player. And, as we all witnessed during the season, Denver can use all the help it can get on offense until McDaniels and staff find their footing.
