Evaluating the Three-headed Committees at Running Back (AFC)
Monday, September 7th, 2009This blog is intended to shed more light on the teams that employ three or more running backs on a regular basis. There won’t be any mention of great RB duos such as the ones in Tennessee or Atlanta because everyone knows the order in which teams like that use their backs. Only the actual “committees” will be chronicled and I will also slot the players into their projected roles this season so you can have a better idea of their expected production.
New York Jets
- Starter (Thomas Jones): He had a career year last year playing behind a re-tooled offensive line and with a hall-of-fame QB. Well the O-line is still there but the QB is not and that will make a big difference. The Jets don’t have the passing game to take pressure off the running backs so Jones will see eight men in the box much more often. In the span of one year Jones has gone from a sleeper to a potential bust.
- 3rd down back (Leon Washington): As one of the best change-of-pace backs in the game, Washington is a big factor in the passing game as well as the running game. He led the NFL in all-purpose yards last season and with a rookie at QB he may get even more reception opportunities. The arrival of Shonn Greene will only affect Jones’ carries, not Washington’s.
- Goal line back (Thomas Jones/Shonn Greene) The Jets drafted Greene to be their eventual starting running back and he may get that role as early as this season. The stocky Greene is perfect for short yardage situations but likely won’t get starter-carries until the Jets are out of playoff contention. Stash him on your bench until he gets more touches later in the season.
New England
- Starter (Fred Taylor): Taylor has started the last two preseason games and is more reliable than Laurence Maroney. The two will split carries and the Patriots will ride whoever is hot at the moment. Sammy Morris will also factor in but he and Maroney have combined to miss 35 games over the last three seasons due to injury/suspension. Taylor, formerly known as “Fragile Fred” has only missed 5 games over the last three years and is the safest draft pick among the Patriot running backs.
- 3rd down back (Kevin Faulk): There’s no doubt about who will have this role as Faulk has been the 3rd down back in all 10 of his seasons with the Patriots. He is worth a pick in PPR leagues, just don’t expect the 507 rushing yards that he had last year.
- Goal line back (Fred Taylor): This could also be Morris but I give the edge to Taylor because he does a better job of holding onto the ball. But once again, New England will probably use whoever is hot and whoever picked up the most yardage on that specific drive. Seeing how Taylor will likely be the one to receive the most rushing opportunities, then he will also be the one to likely get the goal line touches.
Baltimore
- Starter (Ray Rice): With the departure of FB Lorenzo Neal, Le’Ron McClain will return to the fullback position on a full time basis. Rice has the most speed and elusiveness of the three backs and will get the majority of touches. McGahee may have a game here and there where he gets the most carries because his physical running style works better against some opponents than Rice’s style.
- 3rd down back (Ray Rice): This is the only “certainty” among these three roles as Rice had this role last season and is the best option out the backfield for screen passes and checkdowns. But Rice is undersized and struggles in pass protection and that could lead to more third downs for McGahee.
- Goal line back (Willis McGahee/Le’Ron McClain): Most people expect McClain to seize this role but if he’s playing halfback then who’s the fullback? After the release of Jason Cook, McClain is the only fullback on the roster. During preseason McGahee received five of the seven carries for the Ravens inside the five yard line so he appears to be the frontrunner.
Cleveland
- Starter (Jamal Lewis): For now, at least. This situation is similar to Coach Mangini’s former team, the NY Jets, as an aging running back is likely to be phased out at some point this season by a rookie (James Davis). The good news for Lewis is that Mangini likes veteran backs so Lewis will get the opportunity to start the season and show if he still has something left in the tank.
- 3rd down back (James Davis): This was supposed to be Jerome Harrison’s role but he has missed three straight weeks of practice and just returned on August 31. He is likely to have a limited role early in the season while Davis plays on third downs and if Davis impresses then he may keep that role throughout the season.
- Goal line back (James Davis): Despite Lewis’ size, his running style is not suited for short yardage duties. His short, choppy steps are a reason why on his 31 attempts on goal-to-go situations over the last two years, he only has 11 touchdowns. Davis has enough power to push the pile and should be the beneficiary of the goal line touches.






