2008 NFL Awards: Coach of the Year
Tuesday, December 23rd, 2008Some years it’s easy to pick the best players and personel in the league. In 2007 we could look at the league and say, hey, the Patriots are 16-0, Tom Brady threw 50 touchdowns, and Adrian Peterson rushed for 1,341 yards as a rookie, so, you know, I think Bill Belichick should win coach of the year, Brady ought to be MVP, and Peterson is certainly rookie of the year.
But few records are being broken this season and undefeated teams are nowhere to be found. We have surprises everywhere (exhibit A: Atlanta Falcons) and several worthy candidates for all three major awards.
This article examines the five coaches who, in my opinion, have demonstrated they are worthy of being hailed as the best this season.
Bill Belichick (New England Patriots)
Everyone loved to look at the Patriots and say, “As long as Tom Brady and Bill Belichick are there, this is a dangerous team.” Less than a week into the regular season and part one of that equation was lost for the season. But an absent Brady hasn’t been enough to deter Belichick’s Patriots, a hodgepodge of starters and reserve players making a serious run at the postseason. New England has started 40-odd different players this season (translation: lots of injuries). There may be no coach in the NFL better at handling injuries, and Belichick proved so again this season when his MVP quarterback was taken away.
Tony Dungy (Indianapolis Colts)
A rusty Manning, an absent running game, a Swiss cheese-like defense, and the loss of Bob Sanders during the first half of the season left the Colts at 3-4, several games behind an undefeated division rival. Eight weeks and as many wins later and the Colts clinched the postseason. One can argue Manning was a key reason, but it’s ignorant to suggest Dungy had little to do with the turnaround. He proved once again this season he’s in the ranks of Bill Belichick as one of the NFL’s greatest coaches, not only in recent memory, but also in pro football history.
Jeff Fisher (Tennessee Titans)
Jeff Fisher is winning the old-fashioned way: with a stellar defense and uncontainable running game. His Titans clinched the number one seed this weekend with a major victory over the Pittsburgh Steelers and are the team to beat this postseason. Perhaps most impressive is his doing all this without a great quarterback. Kerry Collins is certainly serviceable, but one can’t help but wonder whether he’d be a starter anywhere else in the NFL. Regardless, Fisher is making it work this season with the best team in the AFC.
Mike Smith (Atlanta Falcons)
The Atlanta Falcons were in turmoil last season. The Michael Vick debacle, loss of team morale, and absence of fan support led the Falcons to a state of irrelevance. But look at ‘em now! There’s still a shot they win the NFC South, and they’ll be doing it with a rookie quarterback and a running back who hadn’t started a game since 2004. Smith has turned the Falcons into winners. They’ve won four of their last five and six of their last eight, clinching the postseason after a big victory over the Minnesota Vikings. Smith’s group may be the biggest surprise in the league this season, and much of the credit should go directly to him.
Tony Sparano (Miami Dolphins)
The coach of another team shocking fans this season, Tony Sparano has taken a Dolphins franchise that was in shambles and turned it on its head. There are no elite stars on this team (though Ronnie Brown has been impressive much of the season and Chad Pennington is quietly reviving his career in a big way), but it flat out wins. After a slow start he shook things up on offense and introduced the “Wild Cat,” but that’s more hype than anything else. His entire team is playing at a high level right now. In its four game win streak, the Dolphins kept opponents at 12 points or fewer in three victories.


